IBBI Inducts Mediation for Settlement of Disputes Emanating from the Code
On BACKGROUND
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Code), since its inception has aimed for the swift resolution of stressed companies in the Indian economy, coupled with value maximization for all stakeholders. In furtherance of the said objective, the legislature has time and again examined and explored newer framework within the ambit of the Code, so as to overcome practical and procedural hurdles. One such examination was carried out by the Expert Committee constituted by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI), which studied the scope of mediation for various insolvency, bankruptcy, and liquidation processes under the Code and compiled the same in its report titled ‘Framework for Use of Mediation under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016’ dated 31 January 2024 (Report). The Report highlighted that as on 30 September 2023, of the corporate insolvency resolution process(s) (CIRP) initiated by the operational creditors (OCs), more than 53% were closed on appeal, review or withdrawal and accordingly advocated for resolution of OC disputes via voluntary mediation in the pre-commencement stages of a CIRP.
In furtherance of the above recommendation, the IBBI has on 4 November 2024 published ‘Discussion paper on Mediation by the operational creditors (OCs) before approaching Adjudicating Authority (AA) for filing Section 9 application’ (Discussion Paper) detailing voluntary mediation by the OCs before initiation of a Section 9 application under the Code and suggested appropriate amendments in the IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 (CIRP Regulations).
ISSUES AND PROPOSAL
The Discussion Paper notes that the genesis of majority of Section 9 applications filed under the Code lay in multiple common and recurring disputes which inter alia include (a) disagreements on quality or performance of goods / services provided; (b) contractual disputes with respect to allegations of non-compliance of contractual terms; (c) discrepancies on amount owed or alleged underpayment; (d) claims of the corporate debtor against the OC for set off or damages. Further, most OC initiated cases are fuelled by repayment or recovery of money claims rather than aiming for resolution of the corporate debtor. The Discussion Paper supplements the statistics provided by the Report and further underlines that as on 30 April 2024, 21,466 cases initiated under Section 9 were disposed before admission and only, 3818 cases were admitted. Accordingly, the Discussion Paper observes that the settlement rate of CIRP pre-admission matters for OCs has been larger than at any other stages. However, since the adjudicating authority (AA) has to conduct hearings before accepting or rejecting such Section 9 application, majority of which get settled, the process becomes time consuming and unnecessarily burdens the capacity of the AA.
Hence, the Discussion Paper provides for mediation for earlier resolution of disputes between the OCs and corporate debtors and to facilitate faster adjudication of matters by the AA. It is suggested that a new Regulation 2B may be inserted in the CIRP Regulations which shall provide for mediation as a voluntary option that may be pursued by the OC before initiation of the CIRP. The mediation may be carried out with the aid of a mediator as per the provisions of the Mediation Act, 2023. In the event of failure of mediation, the mediator may prepare a non-settlement report which shall be annexed with the application for initiation of CIRP under Section 9 of the Code.
COMMENTS
The said proposal has the potential to de-clog the AAs of cases emanating solely due to disputes regarding relatively smaller money claims and aimed at recovery. Further, with prior mediation having been conducted, it would also aid the AAs in dispensing swift judgments in applications filed by the OCs, having already had the report from the mediator for reference in their decision making. Having said the above, IBBI may have to watch out for implementation challenges that may crop up especially in the matters of large companies with services being provided by multiple small-time vendors and consequent lack of effective channels for communication for invocation of mediation, service of notice etc. Care must also be taken that the mediators so engaged are well versed with the processes and resolutions under the Code so as to aid and advise the respective parties thoroughly. Further, in the event of breach of such mediation settlement agreement, whether the same shall be first challenged under the Mediation Act, 2003 or used as a ground for initiation of CIRP under Section 9 of the Code is another aspect which may deserve future analysis by the adjudicating authorities.
- Dr. Siddharth Srivastava (Partner), Mohit Kishore (Counsel) and Shikha Mohini (Associate)
For any queries please contact: editors@khaitanco.com
We have updated our Privacy Policy, which provides details of how we process your personal data and apply security measures. We will continue to communicate with you based on the information available with us. You may choose to unsubscribe from our communications at any time by clicking here.
For private circulation only
The contents of this email are for informational purposes only and for the reader’s personal non-commercial use. The views expressed are not the professional views of Khaitan & Co and do not constitute legal advice. The contents are intended, but not guaranteed, to be correct, complete, or up to date. Khaitan & Co disclaims all liability to any person for any loss or damage caused by errors or omissions, whether arising from negligence, accident or any other cause.
© 2024 Khaitan & Co. All rights reserved.
Mumbai
One World Centre
10th, 13th & 14th Floor, Tower 1C
841 Senapati Bapat Marg
Mumbai 400 013, India
Mumbai
One Forbes
3rd & 4th Floors, No. 1
Dr. V. B. Gandhi Marg
Fort, Mumbai 400 001
Delhi NCR (New Delhi)
Ashoka Estate
11th Floor, 1105 & 1106,
24 Barakhamba Road,
New Delhi 110 001, India
Kolkata
Emerald House
1B Old Post Office Street
Kolkata 700 001, India
Bengaluru
Embassy Quest
3rd Floor
45/1 Magrath Road
Bengaluru 560 025, India
Delhi NCR (Noida)
Max Towers,
7th & 8th Floors,
Sector 16B, Noida
Uttar Pradesh 201 301, India
Chennai
8th Floor,
Briley One No.30
Ethiraj Salai
Egmore
Chennai 600 008, India
Singapore
Singapore Land Tower
50 Raffles Place, #34-02A
Singapore 048623
Pune
Raheja Woods
03-108-111, 3 Floor
8, Central Avenue, Kalyani Nagar
Pune - 411 006, India
Gurugram (Satellite Office)
Suite No. 660
Level 6, Wing B,
Two Horizon Center
Golf Course Road, DLF 5
Sector 43, Gurugram
Haryana 122 002, India
Ahmedabad
1506 - 1508, B-Blockr
Navratna Corporate Parkr
Iscon Ambli Road, Ahmedabadr
Gujarat - 380058